Optical machinery maker Hoya Corp., sold at least 13,500 and possibly up to 40,000 eyeglass lenses as impact-resistant when in fact they were no stronger than regular lenses, sources close to the coma…
Optical machinery maker Hoya Corp., sold at least 13,500 and possibly up to 40,000 eyeglass lenses as impact-resistant when in fact they were no stronger than regular lenses, sources close to the comany said on 10 December 2002. Impact-resistant lenses are soaked in a special liquid twice to make them four to eight times stronger than ordinary lenses, which are dipped in the liquid only once. However, to meet delivery schedules, employees dipped the lenses into the liquid only once, the sources said. Impact-resistant lenses, which are much harder to shatter, are priced at about JPY 400 each wholesale and retail for about JPY 2000. Hoya say they will not recall the products or pay refunds on the grounds that the lenses in question are as strong as ordinary products. “There are no safety problems and it is hard to determine whether such lenses were produced without following the correct specifications,” a Hoya employee said. According to Hoya, the lenses were produced at its plants in Minakuhicho, Shiga Prefecture; Tosu, Saga Prefecture; Sapporo; and Hamura, western Tokyo. After someone – believed to be a Hoya employee – revealed the problem in early December, an investigation by the company of the work logbooks and questioning of employees, led to the discovery of irregularities. A total of 8.42 million lenses made under various brand names, including Bifocal1.5 and Hilux Thin Lenticular, have been sold by the company. The company logbooks only date back as far as April 1999, but based on employees“ accounts, Hoya believes that it is highly probable that lenses were not properly processed for an undetermined period of time before the discovery of the irregularities. Hoya estimated that almost 40,000 lenses did not comply with specifications, including those that cannot be confirmed by records,. General Manager Toru Yatabe said an impact test is needed to discover whether the lenses in question were improperly produced. “But even if lenses were produced in line with specifications, they will be damaged by the testing. That is why we cannot order a recall or pay refunds for them. As atonement, our company will donate JPY 100 million, which is more than we have earned from the lenses, to the eye bank,” he said.




